McGlothin Insurance & Financial Services is an independent agency serving Dublin, Lancaster, and all of Ohio. We shop dozens of top-rated carriers so you get the right coverage at the right price — with real people who pick up the phone.
Tell us what you need. We'll do the shopping.
We shop these carriers (and many more) for you
From the car in your driveway to the business you've built, we put together coverage that fits your real life.
Standard, classic, and high-risk auto coverage from carriers that compete for your business.
See options →Homeowners, condo, renters, landlord, flood, and earthquake — built to actually pay out when you need it.
See options →Term, whole life, and final expense. We help you pick the policy that fits your family — not the agent's commission.
See options →General liability, BOP, commercial auto, workers' comp, and surety bonds for Ohio small businesses.
See options →Comprehensive retirement planning, IRAs, income strategies, and risk protection — built in-house by a licensed investment advisor.
See options →Motorcycles, boats, RVs, side-by-sides, classic cars — coverage for the things you actually have fun with.
See options →As an independent agency, we're not loyal to one carrier — we're loyal to our clients. That means we shop dozens of top-rated insurers every renewal and tell you the truth about what you're paying for.
Quick form, quick call, or stop by either office. Whatever's easiest. Five minutes is usually all we need.
We pull quotes from every carrier that fits your situation and put them side-by-side — no jargon, no upsell.
From signing to setup to claims, we stay in your corner — and re-shop every year to keep you covered well.
"I was able to get insurance and a surety bond for half what I was paying. Julie was patient, knowledgeable, and kept me informed every step."
"I currently have 14 policies with McGlothin Insurance. Brock is hands-on and quick to return calls. The only insurance company I'll deal with."
"Awesome customer service and immediate resolution to any issues. I recommend them very highly."
Every six months, we run a fundraising campaign for a local Ohio charity. When you get a quote with us — for anything — we make a contribution on your behalf. No purchase required. Just a quote.
Learn how it works →raised for Ohio charities through client quotes
Free quote. No obligation. We'll tell you straight whether we can do better — or whether you're already in good shape.