McGlothin Insurance & Financial Services' Lancaster office helps families and businesses in Lancaster and Fairfield County find coverage that fits their needs and budget. We're an independent agency, so we don't work for one insurance company. We shop 40+ top-rated carriers and put the options side by side so you can see exactly what you're paying for.
Our main office is in Dublin (see Dublin office).
110 N. Columbus Street, Suite 107
Lancaster, OH 43130
Phone: (740) 653-5230
Hours: Monday–Thursday 9:00 AM–5:00 PM · Friday 9:00 AM–4:30 PM
Standard, classic, and high-risk coverage.
Learn more →Homeowners, condo, renters, landlord, flood.
Learn more →Term, whole life, final expense.
Learn more →General liability, BOP, commercial auto, workers' comp, surety bonds.
Learn more →Planning, IRAs, income strategies.
Learn more →Motorcycles, boats, RVs, side-by-sides, classic cars.
Learn more →Our licensed agents serve clients at both offices, in person, by phone, and online.
Brock founded the agency in 2011 on a simple belief: insurance and financial planning should feel like a conversation, not a sales pitch. He works closely with business owners, families with complex needs, and clients building long-term financial plans.
Clients consistently call out Julie's patience and attention to detail. She has a knack for making complicated coverage feel manageable and keeps clients informed every step of the way.
Laine combines a friendly, approachable style with sharp follow-through. She's the person clients turn to when they need answers fast and want them explained in plain English.
Blake brings a fresh perspective to the agency and a focus on building real relationships with clients. He works across personal and commercial lines and is known for being responsive and easy to work with.
Lexi is detail-oriented, thorough, and great at staying on top of the moving pieces — certificates, renewals, policy changes, claims questions. Clients appreciate that nothing falls through the cracks.
Lancaster, Pickerington, Canal Winchester, Baltimore, Carroll, Pleasantville, Amanda, Bremen, Sugar Grove, Rushville, Lithopolis, Millersport, Thornville, Buckeye Lake, Logan, Circleville, Newark, Pataskala, Reynoldsburg, Groveport, Gahanna, and Columbus, plus the surrounding communities across Fairfield, Franklin, Licking, Pickaway, Perry, and Hocking counties. We write insurance throughout the entire state of Ohio, so wherever you live, we can help.
Call (740) 653-5230 or request a quote online. There's no obligation.